de extinction benefits

^{Benefits of De-Extinction:}

• Scientific knowledge: De-extinction could offer insights into evolution and natural resources that are currently unavailable to us.
• Technological advancement: De-extinction could be a big step forward for genetic engineering.
• Environmental benefits: Threatened or damaged ecosystems could be restored with the help of certain now-extinct species.
• Justice: If people pushed plant and animals species into extinction, perhaps we owe it to these species to try and bring them back.
• Wonder: How cool would it be to see extinct species alive and kicking again?

Why de extinction is bad?

Going through the process of de-extinction could cause some of the pathogens, bacteria, or viruses to come back with them. We have no way of knowing if there would be human contagions associated with some of the creatures, especially if they come from the ancient world.

Why de extinction is good?

References

1. TEDxDeExtinction|Revive & Restore. [ (accessed on 16 May 2018)]; Available online: http://reviverestore.org/events/tedxdeextinction/
2. Revive & Restore The Great Passenger Pigeon Comeback. [ (accessed on 9 July 2018)]; Available online: http://reviverestore.org/about-the-passenger-pigeon/
3. Church G.M. ...
4. O’Connor M.R. ...
5. Biello D. ...
6. Minteer B.A. ...
7. Shapiro B. ...
8. Hirsch R.E. ...

More items...

What are the pros and cons of extinction?

List of Cons of Cloning Extinct Animals

1. It is playing God. In the film Jurassic Park, Ian Malcolm had an argument with John Hammond where he pointed out that dinosaurs “…isn’t some species that was obliterated ...
2. We will be bringing back a species into an environment totally different from the one they lived in. ...
3. It puts the conservation of currently endangered species way back.

Do species benefit from de-extinction?

De-extinction could also help improve ecosystems that had been destroyed by human development by introducing an extinct species back into an ecosystem to revive it. It is also a question whether reviving species driven to extinction by Humans is an ethical obligation.

How does bringing back extinct species help the ecosystem?

Some argue by bringing back extinct species, ecosystems will be thrown out of balance. In many cases however, the exact opposite will occur. Through the extinction of several species, ecosystems became unbalanced as important factors simply disappeared. By reintroducing these species it could help to stabilize damaged ecological areas. For example, there were once grasslands in far north that died out with the absence of the woolly mammoth. If the mammoth was brought back, it could help to reestablish these grasslands ultimately contributing to the reduction of the greenhouse gas effect.

How can reintroduction of extinct species help the future?

The reintroduction of extinct species could be a huge tourism opportunity. People would pay money in order to see these revived wonders in protected habitats. This would be a great way for the field of science to produce a reliable source of income in order to fund research and advancements to push forward into the future. Environmental actions to protect species could be taken along with efforts to clean the environment. De-extinction could help science create a better world for everyone to reside within.

Why would people pay money for science?

People would pay money in order to see these revived wonders in protected habitats. This would be a great way for the field of science to produce a reliable source of income in order to fund research and advancements to push forward into the future.

Abstract

De-extinction projects for species such as the woolly mammoth and passenger pigeon have greatly stimulated public and scientific interest, producing a large body of literature and much debate. To date, there has been little consistency in descriptions of de-extinction technologies and purposes.

1. Introduction

The term de-extinction first gained significant public interest in March 2013 thanks to a series of live-streamed talks at the TEDxDeExtinction event, organized by the conservation non-profit organization Revive & Restore and hosted by National Geographic Society [ 1 ], which simultaneously published an accompanying de-extinction cover story in the March issue of National Geographic magazine.

2. Defining De-Extinction: Replacement by Proxy versus Assisted Recovery

A corrected definition of the mode of de-extinction outlined by the IUCN is this: de-extinction is the ecological replacement of an extinct species by means of purposefully adapting a living organism to serve the ecological function of the extinct species by altering phenotypes through means of various breeding techniques, including artificial selection, back-breeding and precise hybridization facilitated by genome editing.

3. Biotechnology Changes the Concept of Extinction

The issue of redefining extinction in the era of biotechnologically-assisted reproduction is one of ontogeny. Every organism on the planet goes through a single-cell ontogenetic stage, whether asexually or sexually reproducing. However brief, this stage is necessary to complete an organism’s life cycle.

4. Evolutionarily Torpid Species

I propose that reproductively competent single cells be considered ontogenetic individuals of a species and offer a new classification for particular cases when the multi-celled ontogenetic individuals of a species can no longer reproduce without assistance.

5. Limitations of De-Extinction via Breeding

A truly extinct species, subspecies, or genetically unique population, for which no viable cells are preserved cannot currently and may never, be resurrected due to technological and biological limitations.

6. What Is a Proxy?

The classification of proxy populations is very important for navigating the regulatory pathways for introduction to wild habitats, particularly when identifying the native range to which the proxy population will be introduced [ 65 ].

What are the consequences of extinction?

Among the consequences of this wave of extinction are losses of ecosystem services vital to the well-being of humans, such as crop pollination, agricultural pest control, seed dispersal, decomposition and cycling of nutrients, water filtration, and the supply of chemical compounds that may prove essential for novel, life-saving pharmaceuticals.

How many vertebrate species have gone extinct since 1500?

Since the year 1500, at least 322 vertebrate species have gone extinct such as the dodo. Across vertebrates, population abundance has declined by 28 percent over the past four decades with many local populations now extinct. Globally, populations of invertebrates –- insects such as beetles, butterflies, and spiders -- have decreased by 45 percent over the past 40 years.

What would happen if the black plague was teeming with parasites?

If so, the threat to human health could prompt the tantalizingly feasible solution of de-extinction -- that is , resurrecting the big animals and releasing them back into the wild.

What animals are declining in Kenya?

Dirzo's research in Kenya indicates that as large animals such as elephants, giraffes, and zebras decline, grasses and shrubs grow taller and thicker, obscuring rodents from the view of predators and allowing their populations to expand.

How does de-extinction help?

How Will De-extinction Help? 1 If we are able to resurrect species that have become extinct, especially the keystone species, we will also be able to revive ecosystems that have either been damaged or have disappeared. We will be able to use some of these species as flagship species to protect entire ecosystems. Simply put, de-extinction is the need of the hour, if we are to save the fast-depleting environment. 2 If we are able to pull of this feat, it will be a breakthrough in the field of genetic engineering. We will be able to understand what made these species vulnerable to extinction in the first place, and use the information to save related living species. We will also be able to eradicate diseases that are caused by specific genes by introducing immune species in the wild. 3 Most of our knowledge about evolution is based on theories. If we are able to bring back extinct species, we could get an insight into the evolution process. 4 On the morality front, we humans have been responsible for the extinction of a large number of species, including the Tasmanian tiger and Pyrenean ibex. If we are able to bring them back, it will help us undo the harm we have caused over the years―redemption of sorts. 5 And lastly, it will be worth the effort considering that we will be able to see these species, about whom we have only heard, roam the planet.

What are the problems of de-extinction?

The foremost problem with de-extinction will be the lack of resources for the resurrected species. A species brought back from extinction will require a home (habitat) and food. The void these species left when they became extinct has already been filled by new species, and as such, a clash between the two groups will be inevitable.

Is de-extinction a shot in the arm?

Thus, it is far-fetched to say that de-extinction is a shot in the arm for the environment . If at all, it’s just a distraction from real issues. The huge amount of money that we are spending on de-extinction could be used to save species which are on the verge of extinction.

How do extinctions affect biodiversity?

Extinctions not only degrade complexity of an ecosystem’s biodiversity, but can also degrade complex ecological interactions such as food chains, ecosystem engineering, and mutualistic relationships. Restoring the roles of extinct species can be extremely valuable to conservation and is an increasingly considered a solution for ecological problems that stem from past extinctions. When populations go extinct locally, conservationists can reintroduce individuals from a neighboring population ( e.g. wolves to Yellowstone National Park ), or replace an extinct species with a related species (e.g. the Aldabra giant tortoise on Mauritius ).

When did the Great Auk go extinct?

De-Extinction of the great auk. Imagine the iconic flightless bird, the Great Auk, extinct since the mid 19th century, once again swimming throughout the North Atlantic Ocean.

Why is cloning not viable?

Because of avian reproductive biology, cloning or stem cell embryogenesis are not viable reproductive technologies for great auk de-extinction. Instead interspecies germ-line transmission of cultured PGCs will be used. PGCs from a donor bird (species one) are first isolated and subsequently transferred to a recipient bird (species two). This produces a germ-line chimera: a bird that generates both its own germ cells and those of the donor species. When bred, the germ-line chimera can produce offspring from the germ cells of species one.

Can button quail be raised without parental care?

In addition, button-quail chicks can be raised without parental care.

Can chimeras recover from extinction?

Domestic chicken germ-line chimeras could rapidly recover dwindling populations of endangered birds, and in the case of great auk de-extinction, quickly establish a viable captive breeding flock for eventual wild releases. f.

What is de extinction?

De-extinction is a complex topic with extensive background baggage that ranges from the methods in which de-extinction is performed, to the baseline criteria being discussed in today’s world. Because of this, a lot must be understood regarding the behind the scenes research and procedures of this technology in order to fully understand its ethical implications.

How to de-extinct a species?

There are three main methods scientists will use to de-extinct a species, the first of which is back breeding. This method can best be described as creating a “hybrid” species that is a combination of the DNA of an extinct species and that of its closest living relative.

What are the most important animals that are being de-extinction?

As of now, the most well known animals being considered for de-extinction include the Wooly Mammoth and the Passenger Pigeon. Although these are the headliner animals, species such as the Quagga are also being investigated as possible subjects for de-extinction (or already are in the process of being de-extinct)

Why are passenger pigeons important?

The passenger pigeon is a very important ecological species for the habitat that we want to restore. ”. -Should we Bring Extinct Species Back from the Dead. Before europeans settled in what is now north America, it is believed that 20 million acres of forests burned from natural causes each year- now only 4-8 burn.

When did Aurochs go extinct?

Lastly, the “Aurochs”, a very large species of cattle from over 2 million years ago, has also been considered. It became extinct in 1627 at the hands of a poacher, and was first domestication 8,000 years ago as a way to pull heavy loads, and as a meat source.

Can Ibex be brought back?

In the past, scientists have not only successfully brought back the extinct Ibex, but have done a surplus of research surrounding many other animals that have been selected as possible subjects. Through methods of back breeding, genetic engineering, and cloning, extinct species could soon rejoin our environment.

Can a band tail pigeon change its genome?

By starting with the band-tailed pigeon, Ben Novak, a research consultant, says they can change its genome to be extremely close to the previous genetic code of the passenger pigeon- because of this, the resulting animal will not necessarily be a descendent from the passenger pigeon, but will look and act like one.

Why is it important to revive extinct keystone species?

Reviving extinct keystone species, then, could help us preserve biodiversity, and, possibly, the ecosystems as a whole.

Why do we need to save endangered species?

To Save Endangered Species. As humans have taken up more space and resources, we’ve destroyed natural habitats and endangered species. Many of those species eventually go extinct, pushing biodiversity levels below the “safe” threshold — the level at which the ecosystems can regenerate and sustain us — around the globe.

Can genetic engineering be used to bring back extinct species?

The third option — using genetic engineering — is relatively new. With an accurate assembly of an extinct species’ genetic data, researchers can inject them into an egg of a living species that’s genetically close to the one they’re attempting to bring back to life.

Is resurrection biology a noble effort?

Science for science’s sake is a noble effort, but there are also many arguments for “resurrection biology,” which frame the effort as being less about the de-extinction of species that have been lost to us, and more about preventing the extinction of endangered species.

Is de-extinction the answer to the biodiversity crisis that we are facing today?

Advertisement. “De-extinction may not be the answer to the biodiversity crisis that we are facing today, but the technologies that are being developed in the name of de-extinction may become powerful new tools in an active conservation regime,” Shapiro told Smithsonian.

What does it mean to bring back an extinct species?

Bringing extinct species back from the dead could mean letting living species slip away. A new study of de-extinction — the potential to use genetic techniques to recreate lost animals and plants — finds that given limited conservation dollars, the benefits of bringing back one lost species would probably cost the extinction ...

When did the ibex go extinct?

The species went extinct in 2000, but scientist reported in the journal Theriogenology in 2009 that they had cloned an ibex embryo and successfully grew it to term in the uterus of a goat. However, the female baby ibex lived for only a few minutes before dying due to defects in her lungs.

How many birds are de-extinct in New Zealand?

In New Zealand, the theoretical de-extinct species list included eight birds, such as the iconic huia ( Heteralocha acutirostris ), with its curved yellow beak, and the once-plentiful laughing owl ( Sceloglaux albifacies ).

Why are conservationists trying to rethink the ways in which we approach conservation?

"Some conservationists are trying to rethink the ways in which we approach conservation, because some of the standard paradigms aren't as effective as they once were ," Sandler said.

What would happen if New Zealand resurrected 11 species?

For example, if New Zealand resurrected 11 of its extinct species, the government would have to sacrifice the conservation of 33 living species to pay to keep the revived species alive, researchers reported today (Feb. 27) in the journal Nature Ecology & Evolution. "There would be sacrifices," said study author Joseph Bennett, ...

Is de-extinction a problem?

Still, de-extinction is under serious consideration by conservationists and geneticists alike. In 2015, Harvard scientists announced that they had used the gene-editing technique CRISPR to put mammoth genes in the elephant genome, a process that could theoretically result in a sort of woolly mammoth/elephant hybrid.

Has the Pyrenean Ibex been revived?

No one has yet been able to revive an extinct species for any significant stretch of time. The closest thing to a victory so far was the revival of the Pyrenean ibex ( Capra pyrenaica pyrenaica ). The species went extinct in 2000, but scientist reported in the journal Theriogenology in 2009 that they had cloned an ibex embryo and successfully grew it to term in the uterus of a goat. However, the female baby ibex lived for only a few minutes before dying due to defects in her lungs.

Can We Bring Back The Dinosaurs?

How Will De-Extinction Help?

Why Is De-Extinction Not A Good Idea?

De-Extinction Species List